Harvey; Espie (2002) · Insomnia
Harvey; Espie (2002)
Poor Sleep
Disturbed sleep — trouble falling asleep, waking in the night, or unrefreshing sleep. In Harvey's cognitive model the deficit is often overestimated, as attention and worry distort how sleep and daytime tiredness are perceived.
Daytime Fatigue & Worry
Daytime tiredness together with excessive, negatively-toned thinking about sleep and its consequences ('I won't cope', 'I must get eight hours') — worry, rumination and clock-watching that raise arousal.
Compensatory Behaviours
Safety behaviours and counterproductive efforts — napping, extra caffeine, going to bed early, lying in, using screens in bed, and 'trying hard' to sleep. Effortful attempts to sleep paradoxically increase arousal and inhibit sleep's natural automaticity (the attention–intention–effort pathway).
Perpetuating Factors
Perpetuating factors that keep insomnia going after the original trigger has passed — conditioned arousal (the bed becomes a cue for wakefulness and worry), an irregular sleep–wake schedule, and reduced homeostatic sleep drive from extra time in bed and napping.
Selective Monitoring & Misperception
Selective attention, monitoring and misperception (Harvey's cognitive maintainer) — scanning the body and the day for signs of poor sleep and tiredness, and clock-watching at night. This sharpens awareness of, and overestimates, the deficit — so sleep is perceived as worse than it is, feeding back into the cycle.
The published model, shown for reference. Switch to “Blank” to see the empty template you complete with a client.
Most of us sleep badly now and then. Sometimes, though, a run of poor nights turns into ongoing insomnia — and what keeps it going is often different from what set it off. This model shows the cycle that maintains it.
After some bad nights, it's natural to worry about sleep and about coping the next day. But worrying and watching the clock keep the mind and body switched on and alert — the opposite of what sleep needs. We also tend to monitor closely for signs of tiredness, which makes us notice them more.
To cope, people understandably try things that seem to help: napping, extra coffee, going to bed early, lying in, or staying in bed trying hard to drop off. Trying to force sleep tends to backfire, because sleep comes most easily when we stop chasing it.
Over time these habits weaken the body's natural sleep rhythm and turn the bed into a place linked with being awake and worrying rather than sleeping. So poor sleep continues — and the worry, monitoring and habits that were meant to fix it are keeping it going.
How to introduce the model, guided-discovery questions, treatment targets and a behavioural experiment are available to signed-in therapists.
This diagram is a reconstruction of the published model for clinical and educational use, grounded in the sources above.
Formulate provides educational CBT resources for use with a qualified therapist. They are not a substitute for professional assessment, diagnosis, or crisis care.
If you need urgent help now:
Sign up free to open the interactive formulation builder, complete this model collaboratively, and export it as a PDF or share it with your client.