Skip to main content

Theory A vs Theory B

Weigh up two explanations for a fear side by side: that the danger is real (Theory A), or that the problem is worry about the danger (Theory B). Say what each predicts, test Theory B with a planned experiment, then re-rate both. Adapted from Salkovskis and Bass (1997) and Salkovskis, Warwick and Deale (2003).

Written by Tarun Vermani, trainee clinical psychologist Updated

Both buttons open sign-up, then bring you back to this worksheet. No card required. Resource access depends on your plan or trial. Already have an account? Sign in

Worksheet preview

Preview
This worksheet helps you step back and weigh up two possible explanations for what is happening. Theory A is usually the explanation your anxiety gives you (e.g. "I have a serious illness"). Theory B is an alternative (e.g. "I have a problem with worrying about my health"). Fill in both columns, row by row: a few lines in each box is enough, and you don't need to collect every piece of evidence. Rate how much you believe each. Then say what each theory predicts if you act as if Theory B is true, plan a test with your therapist, and afterwards re-rate both.

Live preview: type in any field to try it. Nothing is saved here.

The problem

We all use explanations to make sense of what happens. Sometimes a frightening explanation feels true, but another explanation may fit the facts too. This worksheet sets your current explanation (Theory A) alongside an alternative (Theory B) so you can weigh them up fairly. If you have thoughts of harming yourself or someone else and you are worried you might act on them, tell your therapist. If anyone is in danger, call 999. To talk to someone now, call Samaritans free on 116 123.

Two explanations, side by side

This is the frightening explanation: that the danger is real.

The explanation

The evidence

What I would have to do if it were true

What living by it costs, or gives back

How much I believe it now

Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it
Choose a value
Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it
Choose a value

Weighing it up

Step back and compare the two.

What each theory predicts

If you live by Theory B for that period, what does each theory say will happen? Write each as something you could see or notice.

What will happen

Design the test

The fairest way to tell the theories apart is to act on Theory B and see what happens. Acting on Theory B means easing off worry-driven checking and reassurance; it does not mean ignoring your body. If you have a new or changed physical symptom you have not had looked at, it is sensible to get it checked once in the normal way, and then practise letting the worry be.

Plan the test with your therapist before you try it, and agree which safety behaviours to drop for a fair test. Keep precautions that protect your real health or safety. Do not stop or change any prescribed medication on your own; talk to your prescriber first.

Record 1 of 1

1. Predictions

Choose a value
Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it
Choose a value
Not at allModeratelyExtremely

2. The plan

3. What happened

Choose a value
Not at allModeratelyExtremely

4. What you learned

Choose a value
Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it

After the test: re-rate both

Look back over the whole period. Your first ratings show on each scale, so you can see any shift.

How much I believe it now

Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it

No first rating to compare with. Choose a value

Don't believe itHalf and halfCompletely believe it

No first rating to compare with. Choose a value

Try it here. Nothing you type is saved. Sign up to assign it and let clients complete it on any device.

Get the free OCD bundle by email6 core worksheets as fillable PDFs, plus the interactive formulation. No account needed.

Choose your bundle

When to use ‘Theory A vs Theory B’

‘Theory A vs Theory B’ is an interactive cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) worksheet, most often used in CBT for health anxiety. It is also commonly drawn on when working with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

It is designed to be used within therapy rather than as a standalone self-help tool: a therapist introduces it, works through it collaboratively, and helps make sense of what it surfaces. You can preview the full worksheet above, then assign it digitally for clients to complete between sessions on any device or download it as a print-ready PDF.

How it works

It moves through six short steps:

  1. The problem: We all use explanations to make sense of what happens. Sometimes a frightening explanation feels true, but another explanation may fit the…
  2. Two explanations, side by side
  3. Weighing it up: Step back and compare the two.
  4. What each theory predicts: If you live by Theory B for that period, what does each theory say will happen? Write each as something you could see or notice.
  5. Design the test: The fairest way to tell the theories apart is to act on Theory B and see what happens. Acting on Theory B means easing off worry-driven…
  6. After the test: re-rate both: Look back over the whole period. Your first ratings show on each scale, so you can see any shift.

Completed on the Formulate platform, your client's answers are saved automatically and shared straight back to you, so you can review them before the next session rather than waiting for a paper copy to come back.

The CBT approach behind it

In common with other CBT methods, ‘Theory A vs Theory B’ works by noticing and re-evaluating unhelpful automatic thoughts (cognitive restructuring). The aim is not positive thinking but a clearer, shared understanding of what keeps a difficulty going and practical, testable ways to change it.

Because it is a CBT tool it stays focused on the here-and-now links between thoughts, feelings, the body and behaviour, and it works best as one part of a wider course of therapy rather than as advice or a diagnosis.

Evidence & sources

This worksheet is grounded in established cognitive behavioural therapy theory and practice. Key sources include:

  • Salkovskis, P.M. (1985). Obsessional-compulsive problems: A cognitive-behavioural analysis. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 23(5), 571-583. doi:10.1016/0005-7967(85)90105-6
  • Salkovskis, P.M., & Warwick, H.M.C. (2001). Making sense of hypochondriasis: A cognitive theory of health anxiety. In G.J.G. Asmundson, S. Taylor, & B.J. Cox (Eds.), Health Anxiety: Clinical and Research Perspectives on Hypochondriasis and Related Conditions (pp. 46-64). New York: Wiley.
  • Salkovskis, P.M., & Bass, C. (1997). Hypochondriasis. In D.M. Clark & C.G. Fairburn (Eds.), Science and Practice of Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (ch. 13). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Salkovskis, P.M., Warwick, H.M.C., & Deale, A.C. (2003). Cognitive-behavioral treatment for severe and persistent health anxiety (hypochondriasis). Brief Treatment and Crisis Intervention, 3(3), 353-367.

For use alongside professional support

Formulate provides educational CBT resources for use with a qualified therapist. They are not a substitute for professional assessment, diagnosis, or crisis care.

If you need urgent help now:

  • Emergency services: 999 — if you or someone else is in immediate danger
  • NHS 111 (NHS 24 in Scotland): 111 — choose the mental health option for urgent help, in England, Scotland and Wales (in Wales, press 2)
  • Lifeline: 0808 808 8000 — for urgent help in Northern Ireland, free, day or night
  • Samaritans: 116 123 — free, day or night, 365 days a year
  • Shout: 85258 — text SHOUT, free, day or night
  • SANEline: 0300 304 7000 — 4pm–10pm, every day

More General CBT skills worksheets

View all General CBT skills worksheets →

General CBT skills

Cross-sectional formulation (five-part model)

Map how thoughts, emotions, physical sensations and behaviour affect each other in one situation, using the CBT five-part model.

Formulation~15 minInteractive

General CBT skills

Safety plan

A six-step plan to use when you notice the first signs of a crisis, with a place to note what matters most to you. Complete it with your therapist. Based on the safety planning intervention of Stanley and Brown (2008, 2012), in our own words, with review dates added.

Worksheet~20 minInteractive

General CBT skills

Longitudinal formulation (Beck's cognitive model)

Map how early experiences, core beliefs, rules for living, a critical incident and the cycle that keeps a problem going fit together, using Beck's cognitive model.

Formulation~30 minInteractive

General CBT skills

5-column thought record

A thought record with ratings before and after: name an automatic thought, weigh the evidence for and against it, and write a balanced thought. Based on Greenberger and Padesky (2016): it rates belief in the thought before and after, rates one emotion rather than every mood, and gives each thought its own card.

Worksheet~15 minInteractive

General CBT skills

7-column thought record

An extended thought record, with ratings of emotion and belief before and after, evidence for and against, and a balanced thought. Based on Greenberger and Padesky (2016): it adds a before and after rating of belief in the hot thought, and it rates one emotion rather than every mood.

Worksheet~20 minInteractive

General CBT skills

Cognitive distortions checklist

Spot common unhelpful thinking styles, also called thinking traps or cognitive distortions, in an automatic thought. Then write a more balanced view and rate how much you believe each. Based on Beck et al. (1979): the thinking errors of cognitive therapy set out as a checklist, with belief and distress ratings and a balanced restatement added.

Worksheet~15 minInteractive

Want to assign this to a client?

Create a free therapist account to use the homework and library download tools. Clients can complete assigned homework online or use a blank PDF. See how the homework workflow works.

No card required. The Free plan includes 10 worksheet uses a month. Check plan access and limits.