Skip to main content
CBT Formulation Model

Cognitive Model of Low Self-Esteem

Fennell (1997) · Low self-esteem (transdiagnostic)

Written by Tarun Vermani, trainee clinical psychologist Last reviewed

Fennell's cognitive model of low self-esteem (1997) traces a global negative bottom line back to early experience, and shows how the rules built to manage it end up confirming it through two maintaining cycles.

Cognitive Model of Low Self-Esteem diagram

Fictional worked example: Cognitive Model of Low Self-Esteem. Not a real client.

Cognitive Model of Low Self-Esteem

Adapted from Fennell (1997).

At school I was bullied for my stammer, and at home I was often told to 'stop making a fuss'. My older sister was seen as the clever one.

What is your bottom line about yourself?

I'm stupid and not as good as other people.

How much do you believe it, from 0 to 100?

80

If I never make a mistake, no one will see how stupid I am. If I keep quiet in meetings, I won't be found out. If someone criticises me, it means I'm worthless.

Being asked a question I can't answer at work, getting feedback on my reports and being compared with colleagues.

I'll say something stupid or stammer. They'll realise I don't belong here.

Anxious and dreading it beforehand. My chest goes tight and my mind goes blank.

Over-preparing for hours, staying silent unless asked, asking a colleague to check my work and turning down a training course.

I skip over the good parts of feedback and replay any criticism for days. If something goes well, I put it down to luck or all the preparation, not me.

I'm stupid, and now everyone can see it.

'You made a fool of yourself again. Why can't you just speak properly?'

Ashamed and low for the rest of the day. I just want to hide away.

How the boxes connect

  • Early experiences: leads to The bottom line.
  • The bottom line: leads to Rules for living.
  • Rules for living: leads to When rules are triggered or broken.
  • When rules are triggered or broken: leads to Bottom line activated.
  • Bottom line activated: leads to Negative predictions.
  • Negative predictions: leads to Safety behaviours / avoidance.
  • Anxiety / low mood: two-way link with Negative predictions.
  • Safety behaviours / avoidance: leads to Confirmation of the bottom line.
  • Confirmation of the bottom line: leads to Self-critical thinking.
  • Confirmation of the bottom line: two-way link with Anxiety / low mood.
  • Self-critical thinking: leads to Low mood.
  • Low mood: leads to Bottom line activated.
  • Low mood: leads to Confirmation of the bottom line.

Choose a box name to highlight its connections. Select it again or press Escape to reset.

Choose a box to follow its connections.

Shown for reference. Switch to “Blank” to see the empty template you complete with a client.

Understanding the model

Low self-esteem is more than the odd bad day about yourself — it's a deep-down belief that you're somehow not good enough. This model, developed by Melanie Fennell, shows how that belief takes root and how it keeps proving itself right.

It often grows from early experiences — being criticised, compared unfavourably, bullied, or never quite feeling wanted. Out of these we form a harsh conclusion about ourselves, called the bottom line: 'I'm not good enough', 'I'm unlovable'.

To get by, we build rules to live by — 'as long as I never let anyone down, I'll be okay', 'I must get everything right'. These rules keep the bottom line out of sight, but they're demanding and fragile. When life threatens to break one — a mistake, a criticism, having to say no — the bottom line is stirred up.

From there, two patterns tend to take over. Beforehand, we predict the worst and get anxious, so we over-prepare, avoid, or try too hard to please. Afterwards, we read whatever happened as proof we've failed, and turn on ourselves with criticism and low mood. Both patterns quietly confirm the bottom line — so it stays in charge. Seeing the whole picture is the first step to loosening its grip.

Questions therapists ask about this model.

Frequently asked questions

What are the two cycles?

The anticipatory one runs before the event: the client predicts failure or rejection, becomes anxious, and over-prepares, avoids, or works hard to please. The confirmatory one runs afterwards: whatever happened is read as proof of having failed, bringing self-criticism and low mood. Both quietly confirm the belief, which is why the bottom line survives experiences that ought to unsettle it.

How does it relate to Beck's model of depression?

The shape is similar — early experience, a core belief, rules for living, a trigger that threatens to break one — and both are longitudinal. Fennell's model is written for low self-esteem as a difficulty in its own right rather than for a depressive episode, and it makes the two cycles explicit, including the anxious one that runs ahead of a feared event.

Is low self-esteem a diagnosis in its own right?

No. Fennell (1997) treats it as a difficulty that can stand alone or run through other problems such as depression or anxiety, where it may be a consequence of the current episode or a longer-standing vulnerability beneath it. That is why the model is transdiagnostic. Fennell (1998) describes its place in cognitive therapy, and her self-help guide (Fennell, 1999) sets the same model out for a general readership.

Worksheets and reading for this model

Using this model in session: for therapists

How to introduce the model, guided-discovery questions, treatment targets and a behavioural experiment are available to signed-in therapists.

References

  • Fennell, M. J. V. (1997). Low self-esteem: A cognitive perspective. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 25(1), 1–25.
  • Fennell, M. J. V. (1999). Overcoming low self-esteem: A self-help guide using cognitive behavioural techniques. Robinson.
  • Fennell, M. J. V. (1998). Cognitive therapy in the treatment of low self-esteem. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 4(5), 296–304.

This diagram is a reconstruction of the published model for clinical and educational use, grounded in the sources above.

Cite this page (APA 7)

Vermani, T. (2026). Cognitive Model of Low Self-Esteem. Formulate. https://formulatetools.co.uk/tools/formulation/low-self-esteem-fennell

For use alongside professional support

Formulate provides educational CBT resources for use with a qualified therapist. They are not a substitute for professional assessment, diagnosis, or crisis care.

If you need urgent help now:

  • Emergency services: 999 — if you or someone else is in immediate danger
  • NHS 111 (NHS 24 in Scotland): 111 — choose the mental health option for urgent help, in England, Scotland and Wales (in Wales, press 2)
  • Lifeline: 0808 808 8000 — for urgent help in Northern Ireland, free, day or night
  • Samaritans: 116 123 — free, day or night, 365 days a year
  • Shout: 85258 — text SHOUT, free, day or night
  • SANEline: 0300 304 7000 — 4pm–10pm, every day

Build this formulation with your client

Create a free account to open the interactive formulation builder, complete this model collaboratively and export it as a PDF. Sharing it to your client’s workspace is part of Practice, and every account starts with 14 days of Practice free.

Other formulation models

View all interactive tools →