Challenging guilt and self-criticism
A cognitive worksheet with a compassionate emphasis for guilt and harsh self-criticism. Weigh the evidence, see what else contributed, and find a fairer view, the kind you would offer a good friend. Based on Greenberger and Padesky (2016): a thought record and responsibility pie, with a before-and-after share, a repair step and compassionate framing from Gilbert (2010) added.
Written by Tarun Vermani, trainee clinical psychologist Updated
Both buttons open sign-up, then bring you back to this worksheet. No card required. Resource access depends on your plan or trial. Already have an account? Sign in
Worksheet preview
Challenging guilt and self-criticism
PreviewLive preview: type in any field to try it. Nothing is saved here.
The situation
Start by anchoring the thought in a specific moment. What was happening when the guilt or self-criticism showed up?
The thought and the feeling
Now capture the guilt or self-critical thought as closely as you can to the words it used, and notice how strongly it lands.
If the harsh things you write about yourself here turn into thoughts of hurting yourself, use your safety plan if you have one, and tell your therapist or care team. If you feel unsafe right now, call 999 or go to A&E. To talk to someone now, call Samaritans free on 116 123.
Looking at the evidence
A self-critical thought tends to gather only the evidence that supports it. Here we slow down and look at both sides, as fairly as we can.
A fairer look at responsibility
Guilt often hands us 100% of the blame. In reality, most outcomes have several contributing factors. Before deciding how much is genuinely yours, notice everything else that played a part. This is sometimes called the responsibility pie.
First rate how much feels like yours. Then give each other factor a rough percentage. Last, rate your own share again, so that all the slices together add up to about 100%.
| # | Contributing factor | Rough share (%) | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
The view from a friend's side
We are often far harsher with ourselves than we would ever be with someone we care about. Borrowing that kinder, wiser voice can help us see the situation more fairly.
A fairer, more balanced thought
Drawing the evidence, the fuller picture of responsibility, and the compassionate view together, write a thought that is both fair and kind. A balanced thought is not falsely positive. It simply tells the whole truth, including the parts the critic left out.
Try it here. Nothing you type is saved. Sign up to assign it and let clients complete it on any device.
When to use ‘Challenging guilt and self-criticism’
‘Challenging guilt and self-criticism’ is an interactive cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) worksheet, most often used in CBT for low self-esteem.
It is designed to be used within therapy rather than as a standalone self-help tool: a therapist introduces it, works through it collaboratively, and helps make sense of what it surfaces. You can preview the full worksheet above, then assign it digitally for clients to complete between sessions on any device or download it as a print-ready PDF.
How it works
Most people work through it in around 20 minutes. It moves through six short steps:
- The situation: Start by anchoring the thought in a specific moment. What was happening when the guilt or self-criticism showed up?
- The thought and the feeling: Now capture the guilt or self-critical thought as closely as you can to the words it used, and notice how strongly it lands. If the harsh…
- Looking at the evidence: A self-critical thought tends to gather only the evidence that supports it. Here we slow down and look at both sides, as fairly as we can.
- A fairer look at responsibility: Guilt often hands us 100% of the blame. In reality, most outcomes have several contributing factors. Before deciding how much is genuinely…
- The view from a friend's side: We are often far harsher with ourselves than we would ever be with someone we care about. Borrowing that kinder, wiser voice can help us…
- A fairer, more balanced thought: Drawing the evidence, the fuller picture of responsibility, and the compassionate view together, write a thought that is both fair and…
Completed on the Formulate platform, your client's answers are saved automatically and shared straight back to you, so you can review them before the next session rather than waiting for a paper copy to come back.
The CBT approach behind it
In common with other CBT methods, ‘Challenging guilt and self-criticism’ works by noticing and re-evaluating unhelpful automatic thoughts (cognitive restructuring). The aim is not positive thinking but a clearer, shared understanding of what keeps a difficulty going and practical, testable ways to change it.
Because it is a CBT tool it stays focused on the here-and-now links between thoughts, feelings, the body and behaviour, and it works best as one part of a wider course of therapy rather than as advice or a diagnosis.
Evidence & sources
This worksheet is grounded in established cognitive behavioural therapy theory and practice. Key sources include:
- Gilbert, P. (2010). Compassion Focused Therapy: Distinctive Features. London: Routledge. doi:10.4324/9780203851197
- Gilbert, P., & Procter, S. (2006). Compassionate mind training for people with high shame and self-criticism: Overview and pilot study of a group therapy approach. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 13(6), 353-379. doi:10.1002/cpp.507
- Greenberger, D., & Padesky, C.A. (2016). Mind Over Mood (2nd ed.). New York: Guilford Press.
For use alongside professional support
Formulate provides educational CBT resources for use with a qualified therapist. They are not a substitute for professional assessment, diagnosis, or crisis care.
If you need urgent help now:
- Emergency services: 999 — if you or someone else is in immediate danger
- NHS 111 (NHS 24 in Scotland): 111 — choose the mental health option for urgent help, in England, Scotland and Wales (in Wales, press 2)
- Lifeline: 0808 808 8000 — for urgent help in Northern Ireland, free, day or night
- Samaritans: 116 123 — free, day or night, 365 days a year
- Shout: 85258 — text SHOUT, free, day or night
- SANEline: 0300 304 7000 — 4pm–10pm, every day
More Low self-esteem worksheets
View all Low self-esteem worksheets →Low self-esteem
Low self-esteem formulation (Fennell's cognitive model)
Map how early experiences leave a harsh bottom line about yourself, the rules for living that protect it, and the cycle that seems to prove it again, using Fennell's cognitive model of low self-esteem.
Low self-esteem
Low self-esteem formulation (quick version)
A quicker version of Fennell's model of low self-esteem, in five boxes: early experiences, the bottom line, rules for living, what breaks them, and the cycle that seems to confirm it.
Low self-esteem
Self-compassion worksheet
Practise answering your self-critical voice with the kindness you would offer a friend, and see how your feelings change. Based on Gilbert (2009): the compassionate response to self-criticism, set out as a three-part entry with a rating of the feeling before and after.
Low self-esteem
Strengths and qualities record
Collect evidence of your strengths, qualities and achievements, especially the ones your old belief makes you miss. Based on Fennell (1998): a day-to-day record of positive qualities, with a rating of the old belief at the start and end of the week and a reflection added.
Low self-esteem
Self-criticism monitoring record
A diary for catching your inner critic in the moment: what it says, the tone it uses, and the effect it has on you. Watch it with curiosity before working on changing it. Based on Gilbert (2009) and Fennell (1997): a plain monitoring record; the compassion-focused and cognitive work that follows is left out.
Low self-esteem
Social comparison and self-worth
A plain-language explainer on why comparing ourselves to others is normal, how it can quietly feed low self-worth, especially on social media, and what helps. Based on Festinger (1954): people judge themselves by comparing with others; upward and downward comparison, the insides versus outsides idea and social media are added.
Want to assign this to a client?
Create a free therapist account to use the homework and library download tools. Clients can complete assigned homework online or use a blank PDF. See how the homework workflow works.
No card required. The Free plan includes 10 worksheet uses a month. Check plan access and limits.